Pasacaglia: From Spanish street songs to baroque masterpieces

16

It starts in the streets. The word passacaglia comes from the Spanish word pasacalle, which literally means “street song”. By the time the dance reached European courts, it had changed from a potentially intense and offensive dance to an exercise in imposing majesty. But if you thought the transition was smooth sailing, think again. History is a mess.

In 17th century Spain, this dance was not strictly an upper class dance. It has a reputation. It’s fast and hot, so it’s definitely not for the faint of heart. Fast forward to the 17th and 18th centuries in France, and the same dance became stately. Valuable. Royal. What are the practical steps? Gone. Lost to time. We don’t know the footwork. All we know is music.

The Chaconne Problem

This is the hard part. Musically, the passacaglia is almost identical to the chaconne. They are so close that baroque composers used the terms interchangeably. You will find rondeaux (songs with repeated refrains) and variations marked as one of them. It’s a jargon that even contemporary writers have a hard time figuring out.

But they tried. Writers of the time argued that the passacaglia was the more “graver” of the two dances. They also noted that it is often associated with male dancers. Why? Probably because it’s heavy. Probably because it requires more endurance. We can only guess.

The differences in definitions can be explained by two main theories. The first is that chaconne music is a series of variations on a briefly repeated bass theme (basso ostinato ). From this point of view, in the passacaglia the theme appears in any voice, not just in the bass.

Another theory flips the script. Demonstrates the use of ostinato in a passacaglia. Usually in the bass part, but sometimes used elsewhere. Chaconne differs, however, in its harmonic ground. Think of it as a jazz riff. A series of chords that underpins the music. A baseline may exist, but it is only an integral part of harmony, not a structural anchor. Which one is correct? Probably both. Probably neither. Musicologists still argue about it.

Why it matters now

Even if you don’t know the name, you may have heard the form. It has survived centuries of musical development. Consider Bach’s Passacaglia and Fugue in C minor (BWV 582). It is famous for a reason. This structure is held together by an almost physical tension.

It’s not just a baroque style. Aaron Copland composed the piano passacaglia in 1921-1922. Dmitri Shostakovich used this form in the fourth movement of his Eighth Symphony in 1943. Alban Berg included a passacaglia in Act 1, Scene 4 of his opera Wozzeck (1922). The form adapts. It bends. It continues.

How about dancing? It hasn’t disappeared. It just changes shape. The original name survives in the “pasacalle”, a lively folk dance for couples popular in western South America. Fast